Monday, 3 September 2012

2012 - The Year of Open Access

This year will be remembered as the year that Open Access went mainstream. This whole movement represents a significant change in the field of science. It has led to a widespread realisation that closed access publishers by definition do not have scientists' interests at heart (maximum dissemination of their work) along with a recognition that scientists needs to engage with the wider community, not just their peers in ivory towers. In the end, it all came down to the funders.

For my own part, over the past number of years I have become increasingly convinced that all scientific work should be freely available and preferably Open Access, CC-BY* and copyright me (hey - if I'm going to pay, I want it AALLLLLL!!). I want people to read my work and I want people to be free to remix and reuse it in any way they want - this is the essence of this thing we call science. Burying work in non-OA journals, or worse still in books that few will have access to let alone read, seems to me to be a baaad idea, and especially so now that the writing is on the wall (not literally of course, it's usually on the web).

Others have recounted the events so far this year but here they are again:
Jan - The year started at a low point, a motion in the US to repeal the NIH's public access policy, the Research Works Act. It turned out that Elsevier were behind this.
Feb - After a major outcry, and Tim Gower's announcement that he would boycott Elsevier (subsequently supported by 12K others), Elsevier dropped the bill.
Jun - The Wellcome Trust starts cracking the whip on its OA compliance (only 55% of funded publications were compliant). In future, non-compliance will mean grant money will be withheld, and non-compliant publications will be ignored for the purposes of applying for further funding. Furthermore, publications must be effectively CC-BY.
Jul - The Research Councils of the UK (RCUK) mandate OA, and specifically CC-BY.
Jul - The EU is talking about mandating OA for the 2014-2020 framework funding.
Aug - Wiley announces that its OA journals will now adopt CC-BY.

Historic times. For more, see this link.

*Note: CC-BY is a copyright license developed by the Creative Commons. It's very simple. It means you can legally do whatever you want with the article, so long as you acknowledge the copyright holder. For more info, see the license.

Bibliometricking J Cheminf

Just for fun, a week or two ago I decided to check out who are the most prolific authors in J. Cheminf. I downloaded the TOC in Endnote format from the journal website, and analysed it with the short script below.

There were 295 authors in total (after merging of I think a single duplicate), and all of the authors with 2 or more papers are as follows (by no. of publications, then reverse alphabetical by surname):
14 Peter Murray-Rust
8 Stephen Bryant
8 Evan Bolton
7 Sam Adams
6 Egon Willighagen
6 Joe Townsend
6 Sunghwan Kim
5 Andreas Zell
5 Antony Williams
5 Andreas Jahn
5 Georg Hinselmann
4 David Wild
4 Christoph Steinbeck
4 Noel O'Boyle
4 Geoffrey Hutchison
3 Tim Vandermeersch
3 Henry Rzepa
3 Lars Rosenbaum
3 Matthias Rarey
3 Stefan Kramer
3 David Jessop
3 Nina Jeliazkova
3 Marcus Hanwell
3 Nikolas Fechner
3 Peter Ertl
2 Erik van Mulligen
2 Peter Willett
2 Valery Tkachenko
2 Jens Thomas
2 Ola Spjuth
2 Christopher Southan
2 Weerapong Phadungsukanan
2 Ben O'Steen
2 Sorel Muresan
2 David Lonie
2 Andrew Lang
2 Jan Kors
2 Jos Kleinjans
2 Andreas Karwath
2 Jochen Junker
2 Vedrin Jeliazkov
2 Craig James
2 Jonathan Hirst
2 Kristina Hettne
2 Lezan Hawizy
2 Martin Gutlein
2 Rajarshi Guha
2 Mikhail Elyashberg
2 Michel Dumontier
2 Ying Ding
2 Open Source Drug Discovery Consortium
2 Leonid Chepelev
2 Fabian Buchwald
2 Jean-Claude Bradley
2 Kirill Blinov
...and here's the script used to calculate this:

Wednesday, 22 August 2012

Transforming molecules into...well...other molecules

It's fairly straightforward to filter structures by SMARTS patterns using Open Babel, but how about if you want to transform all occurences of a particular substructure into something else? This may be useful for structure cleanup, tautomer normalisation, or even to carry out a reaction in silico.

Anyhoo, that's enough background. Let's suppose we want to hydrogenate all instances of C=C and C=O. Just copy and paste the following into the end of plugindefines.txt:
OpTransform
hydrogenate      # ID used for commandline option
*                # Asterisk means "no datafile specified"
Hydrogenate C=C and C=O double bonds
TRANSFORM [C:1]=[C:2] >> [C:1][C:2]
TRANSFORM [C:1]=[O:2] >> [C:1][O:2]
This gives a new obabel option, --hydrogenate, that will do the job:
C:\Tools\tmp>obabel -L ops
...
hydrogenate    Hydrogenate C=C and C=O double bonds
...
C:\Tools\tmp>obabel -:C=C -osmi --hydrogenate
CC
C:\Tools\tmp>obabel -:O=CSC=CC=S -osmi --hydrogenate
OCSCCC=S
Notes:
(1) This works best in the latest SVN as Chris sorted out some longstanding bugs.
(2) I've just enabled this in Python where it works as follows:
import pybel
transform = pybel.ob.OBChemTsfm()
success = transform.Init("[C:1]=[C:2]", "[C:1][C:2]")
assert success
mol = pybel.readstring("smi", "C=C")
transform.Apply(mol.OBMol)
assert mol.write("smi").rstrip() == "CC"

Wednesday, 15 August 2012

Using cheminformatics to guide your career path

Leaving aside the fact that the term scientific career is a bit of an oxymoron, I propose to show how considering the distribution of alpine flora can help guide your career choices. When Jaccard first headed for the alps to count edelweiss, little did he know he would make a stunning discovery that would change the face of cheminformatics forever - the Tanimoto coefficient. Here I show how to extend this coefficient to career path planning.

Simply put, you should choose your next institution based on whether it has a high Tanimoto coefficient with your current. Let's take my career as an example and show how this works:

1997-2001 University College Galway, UCG
2001-2004 Dublin City University, DCU (Tanimoto coefficient of 2/4 = 0.5)
2004-2005 University College Dublin, UCD (3/3 = 1.0)
2005-2006 Unilever Centre Cambridge, UCC (2/4 = 0.5)
2006-2009 Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre, CCDC (2/5 = 0.4)
2009-         University College Cork, UCC (2/5 = 0.4)

As with any career there were some highs (Tanimoto of 1.0) and some lows (values of 0.4). Now the question is, what about my next move?

Notes: UCG is now NUIG (National University of Ireland, Galway).

Tuesday, 14 August 2012

Grant me that - My non-funding history

A successful PI here in UCC made the point to me (after a grant application of mine was bounced) that only about 1 in 6 applications of his are funded. This may have been a white lie, but I thought it'd be interesting to look back on all of my applications since I finished my PhD and see how it's gone for me (items in bold were funded):

 2005 - Marie Curie Intra-European Fellowship
 2006 - Royal Commission for the Exhibition of 1851
 2006 - EPSRC Project Grant (minor contribution)
 2007 - President of Ireland Young Researcher Award
 2008 - SFI Principal Investigator
 2008 - Wellcome Trust Research Career Development Fellowship
 2008 - Health Research Board Career Development Fellowship
 2009 - CSA Trust Jacques-Émile Dubois Grant
 2009 - SFI Starting Investigator Research Grant
 2009 - Wellcome Trust Research Career Development Fellowship
 2010 - CSA Trust Jacques-Émile Dubois Grant
 2011 - European Research Council Starting Grant
 2011 - IRCSET Enterprise Partnership Scheme
 2011 - SFI Starting Investigator Research Grant

Note that a couple of researchers out there are going a bit further than me, and actually posting up their grant applications. Check them out (via +Jan Jensen).

Image credit: The above image of Grant's Tomb (geddit?) is by ScottOldham (CC-BY-SA).

It all adds up to a new descriptor Part II


As described in an earlier post, it's pretty easy to implement a new group contribution descriptor with Open Babel just by editing a text file. Well, that post inspired Andy Lang to use this feature to develop a melting point model which you can download right now and apply using Open Babel.

You can read the announcement of the model on the OB mailing list or get the model and read all the details including exactly how it was developed over at Jean-Claude Bradley's Open Notebook Science wiki. The image above by Andy Lang shows the performance of the model on a test set ([Update 02/2018]: see image at Figshare instead).

Wednesday, 8 August 2012

Presentations and Practicals from Resources for Computational Drug Discovery

As discussed previously, I recently presented on the topics of cheminformatics and protein-ligand docking. The talks were slightly updated for the occasion, and are included below.

I also supervised a practical on cheminformatics involving the Open Babel GUI. This will be available as part of the regular OB documentation, but in the meanwhile, you can access it at ReadTheDocs. It covers file format conversion (surprise!), depiction, filtering, and similarity and substructure searching.

Here's my cheminformatics talk:

...and my protein-ligand docking talk: